The following is a project I assign my 12th grade English classes. I teach large classes of about 40 students each, and take advantage of if it by assigning this big, complex project called "The Perfect Country Project". The basic idea is that my classes take some debate topics we use in class to poll people outside of school in Bangkok. They get into specialized teams, collect the polls, analyze the information, and give a PowerPoint presentation at the end of the term.
Below is the project in detail. I couldn't figure out how to upload a file to this blog, so I just copy and pasted it. It's quite long and complex. A rubric is included. After the details of the assignment, a link to my screencast can be found below.
The
Perfect Country Project
Teacher:
Aj.
Glenn Verasco
Classes:
48, 49, 58, 59, 80, 81, 125, 126, 143, 222, 223, 224
Due
Dates: Progress Report: July 8th
Presentations:
The last day of class before finals
Objective: For
the next few weeks, we will be discussing the dichotomy of “Tradition vs.
Progress”. We will do some reading in Pathways, and debate and discuss
various topics as a class. Unfortunately, our class demographic is not
particularly diverse (we’re all Thai 12th graders [except for me!]).
The purpose of this project is to get a more varied and worldly view of these
topics. Your assignment is to poll about 800 people as a class so we can get an
idea of what the average person thinks. You will not only look at the grand
totals of the poll results, but will also find differences and similarities
between the sexes, age groups, and many nationalities. You will be working as a
team, and must all do your part to make this project happen.
Evaluation:
Category/Score
|
5.5
|
4.125
|
2.75
|
1.375
|
Content
|
Full
of quality information
|
Some
very good content
|
Not
enough information and seems flawed
|
Not
at all educational and most likely inaccurate
|
Analysis/
Comprehension
|
Brilliantly
critiqued and evaluated; you really get it!
|
Some
thoughtful criticism and mostly understood
|
A
few decent points, but could use some more thought
|
Not
well thought out or comprehended
|
Organization
|
Absolutely
ready to be presented and flawlessly delivered
|
Given
plenty of thought ahead of time with little confusion
|
Should
have been better prepared, but a decent outcome
|
Not
ready to be presented and disappointing
|
Aesthetics
|
Includes
photos of procedure; a pleasure to view
|
Nice
looking and clear; includes photos
|
Not
particularly nice to look at, but not bad
|
Unclear,
dull, and lazily done
|
Value: 30 points (4 points for the progress report, 22
points for the final project, 2 points for self-evaluation, 2 points for
evaluation from the management team)
Teams
and Responsibilities:
*** EVERY STUDENT IS RESPONSIBLE FOR COLLECTING
10 POLLS FROM THAI NATIONALS AND 10 POLLS FROM FOREIGNERS***
Management Team (3-5 students):
-
Oversee the entire project
-
Attend Q&A meeting in room 262 with Aj.
Glenn (Wednesday, June 1st)
-
Create a checklist to use for completing each
part of the project
-
Keep track of which students are in which
groups
-
Make sure all students have taken care of
their responsibilities efficiently
-
Hand in progress report the week before
midterms (this covers your class’s formative 1 score)
-
Evaluate each student at the completion of
the project
Poll Team (4-6 students):
-
Create 10 poll statements (suggested
themes provided by Aj. Glenn)
-
Translate poll statements into Thai (or
English if you wrote them in Thai first)
-
Translate “Mission Statement” from English
to Thai
-
Have poll statements approved by Aj. Glenn
(June 17th at the latest)
-
Predict how different demographics will
vote on each topic (must be done before polls are collected)
Design Team (6-10 students):
-
Design and create anonymous poll sheet
o
Must include:
§ Poll
statements
§ Age
§ Gender
§ Nationality
§ Mission
Statement (can be on a separate sheet of paper)
-
Use collected data to create a PowerPoint presentation
(graphs, charts, tables, photos, etc…)
-
Help Presentation Team prepare for
presentation
-
Collect photographs of entire process
Data Team (8-12 students):
-
Collect completed polls from all
classmates (20 per classmate)
-
Organize collected data based on the following
criteria
o
Grand totals
o
Thai vs. Foreign grand totals
o
Male vs. Female grand totals
o
Thai Male vs. Thai Female totals
o
Foreign Male vs. Foreign Female totals
o
Age group grand totals
o
Thai age groups
o
Foreign age groups
-
Deliver data to the design team
Analysis Team (5-7 students):
-
Thoroughly answer analysis questions
(provided by Aj. Glenn)
-
Find other notable trends and results within
data
-
Explain findings to presentation team
Presentation Team (4-6 students):
-
Answer questions about the process of completing
the project (provided by Aj. Glenn)
-
Present project results to class at the
end of the semester (it should be as long as one class period)
Mission
Statement and Poll Statements
The following is the mission statement for our
project. You can let English speakers read this as I have written it before
they participate, and must translate it into Thai for Thai speakers.
Dear
Friend,
Our
class has been discussing and debating what policies a “perfect country” would
have. As a class, we agree on certain topics, but disagree on others. Now, we
want to find out what policies other people think would make a perfect country.
We
would greatly appreciate your anonymous participation in our study, and promise
to invite you for an all-expenses-paid trip to our perfect country once it has
been founded!
Thanks
for your help! J
-The
Perfect Country Project Team (Triam Udom Suksa School)
Making
the Poll Statements (Poll team)
Your poll questions should
be in the form of a statement. This is called a “Likert Scale”.
Chocolate
ice cream is the best kind of ice cream in the world.
___ Totally Agree ___ Agree ___ No Opinion ___ Disagree ___ Totally Disagree
Our poll questions will be a
bit more serious than chocolate ice cream. Here are five sample questions for
your poll (you may use one of these for your poll if you would like).
1.
It should
be legal for committed homosexual couples to adopt children.
2.
Wages
should be negotiated by employers and employees without government
interference.
3.
All able
male citizens should be required to serve in the military for at least two
years.
4.
Taxes
should be high so the government can provide social welfare like education,
healthcare, food, and housing for the less fortunate.
5.
Abortion
should be illegal except in cases of rape or a threat to the mother’s health.
Remember, your polls should be controversial (meaning people will disagree with each other about
them). If you use a statement like “murder should be illegal”, everyone
will choose the same answer, and we will learn nothing. Try to think about
“Tradition and Progress” when making your poll questions. Here are some themes
you can think about when creating polls:
-
Taxes
-
Economics
-
The Environment
-
Gay Marriage
-
Abortion
-
The Death Penalty
-
Immigration
-
Military
-
Citizenship
-
Form of
Government
-
Freedom of
Religion
-
Freedom of
Speech
-
Education
-
Prostitution
-
Voting
-
Trade
-
Foreign Policy
-
Healthcare
-
Etc…
***A perfect poll will have
5 statements from a traditional (Conservative) point of view, and 5 statements
from a progressive (Liberal) point of view.***
Designing
the poll (Design team)
The way you design your poll
is up to you. But here are a few requirements, and a few suggestions.
Requirements
1.
It must include
all ten statements and space to fill out the poll.
2.
It must include
a space for the participants to write their age, gender, and nationality.
3.
The “Mission
Statement” must be viewable for participants.
4.
Since the polls
are anonymous, the poll must
not ask for participants’ names.
Suggestions
1.
Try to use as
little paper as possible for environmental and monetary reasons.
2.
Use recycled
paper.
3.
Keep the
“Mission Statement” separate from the polls, and have it displayed on a
clipboard to save paper.
Questions
(for Presentation Team and Analysis Team)
Presentation
Team
1. Please
explain the process you used to complete this project.
2. Where
did you find people to participate in the poll?
3. What
did you think would be the most difficult part of completing the project?
4. What
turned out to be the most difficult challenge you faced?
5. What
did you enjoy about completing this project?
6. What
did you learn from participating in this project?
Analysis Team
Expectations (to be answered before data
is collected)
1. Of
the ten statements, which do you think come from the most extremely traditional
and extremely progressive points of view?
2. Which
demographics do you predict will vote the most progressively, and which will be
the most traditional?
3. What
are some other predictions you have for how the polls will turn out?
4. Do
you think the project will be successful? Why or why not?
Basic Results
1. Which
statement had the highest overall approval rating?
2. Which
statement had the lowest overall approval rating?
3. Which
statement was the most controversial? (had the most people voting “totally
agree” and “totally disagree”)
4. Which
demographics voted most similarly?
5. Which
demographics voted most differently?
6. On
which statements did men and women disagree the most?
7. On
which statements did Thais and foreigners disagree the most?
8. On
which statements did different age groups disagree the most?
Critical Thinking
1. Please
explain what you think the purpose of this project was.
2. By
your definitions, which demographic voted the most traditionally, and which
voted the most progressively?
3. Why
do you think certain demographics voted in certain ways?
a. Thais
b. Foreigners
c. Males
d. Females
e. Different
Age Groups
f. Etc…
4. Which
results were the most surprising and why?
5. Critique
the project and its results: Is doing a project like this useful? Why? What are
the project’s flaws?
6. How
seriously should we take the results of the polls?
BEST OF LUCK!!! J
Click here to see my screencast!
Your screencast is not embedded (or linked).
ReplyDeleteIt should be fixed now.
Delete